September 14th 2010
email from me
I’m writing. I know.
I know I know I know.
Just…
Please.
I keep thinking about what you were saying, about feeling the blame for my health and creativity.
um.
From the very beginning. From the first long drive home to Ocean Grove and the conversations in the dark of my bedroom… I wanted to give you at least one person who’d be safe. One person to joyfully hang out with on Halloween or Christmas or whenever, to be un-inebriated with amongst the crowd of screaming retards. and. One person to possibly almost sort of trust yourself with. Have “faith” in. To be safe with in different ways.
And that’s why I fell apart sobbing in my driveway, collapsing into your arms. Because… regardless of whatever logic and justifiable reasoning and hurt that might have preceeded it, my actions when we were apart were something that … butchered in you exactly what I’d wanted to preserve and grow and give you.
And after the show, when you told me what had upset you, I held it together driving back from Brooklyn, but I was tear-welling the whole time until I ended up home, and I was trying really really hard not to accidentally cry in front of <your friend>, and I thought he caught me once or twice. Because there, too, I’d wanted to be at least ONE person in your life with whom you could be not just the solitary sober person. One person to have a fun and beautiful time that could be unmarred by dirt and grime. A person worth trusting in the world that keeps disappionting you. To prove that I could be something good. And i’d failed.
I’ll feel awful for that forever. For both. I’ll always hate part of myself and be disappointed in the person that I was. Because. I failed. At everything I wanted to be for you. And because it was what I wanted to be for you, it was the most important goal I had, really.
But I didn’t do those things knowing the affect they’d have. In that respect, I didn’t do anything wrong. But that doesn’t change the effect, and it doesn’t change the shame and hurt I feel for causing it.
Same as you. Same as my health and my art.
We aren’t in each other’s brains. We simply can’t get everything right. Maybe we had high expectations because of how amazingly well we fit and supported each other, and thought we would continue to do so in every way, in every situation.
That’s why I brought up the driving to the show example. Not as a hated character flaw, but as something that I can’t always SEE through….. and it will lead me (and others) down paths that will unintentionaly hurt you (and others), and which will only lead you to pull even further away from anyone – miscommunication that will lead you to be a “disappointment to” and/or “disappointed of” those around you. I brought it up in the hopes that you might be able to spare yourself some vicious cycles of hurt and lonliness. I brought it up because I don’t want to end up hurting you again.
You didn’t do the things you did to to make me stress-sick and grey-brained. You’ve done what you’ve done to try and find yourself in your own head, not thinking you’d have such an effect. So did I. So please don’t say things on purpose just to hurt.
You’ve still been more actively accepting and understanding of my health than anyone, and more actively supportive of my art than anyone. Nobody else is still willing to be near me AND be patient. Yeah, there’s other people who haven’t caused me the same sort of hurt and harm, but they’ve always been at a distance. It’s better to be close to someone and occasionally get an elbow in the ribs, than to never touch at all.
The thing is, things like my health and my art… they are a holistic part of me. The best way for me to feel inspired and active and trying at art, and the best way for me to take my sickness in stride and not be all consumed by it is… to have the wonderful and fabulousness that I saw in us together. To feel I belong with someone, and that I’m understood. To have one person that I’d give everything for. And to feel that person feel all that back at me.
And what kills art, what makes everything seem ashen and grey, what magnifies every panic and pain, is to be broken hearted and feel so much of I thought I had in you be whisked away, and be left in an mist without the merest definition.
I wish it didn’t hurt to be close with you, and the have the longing and the gasping for air that comes with having no ground under my feet. But it does, and it just makes the hurt grow.
So, I guess this is a state of… emotional chemotherapy.
Hoping that with enough time and examination, the hurt will shrivel up and die away, and what’s left is strong enough to survive and flourish. As a different life.
Or maybe we’ll end up succumbing to the poison in this slow weakening treatment of diminishment. And be dead to one another.
Right now hairless and gasping for air. On the brink.
I just can’t help but think what a terrible shame it is that we should have been supporting each other through this time of stress, could have been helping each other. Could have been enjoying the possibility of discarding the lives that haven’t treated us well, and the people who don’t fit, and embracing new futures.
New futures that were built with each other in mind.
If things were different, I’d have enjoyed setting up the archetecture of my new life around meshing with yours. Being fabulous together. Stronger than the sum of our parts.
I’m not sure I understand why you never thought to offer me even just a temporary refuge at your home when I got kicked out, after you’d spent a third of your time with me at mine for years. Or why not maybe welcomed me into just visiting your house more while I’ve been so clearly trapped and isolated and not doing well in New Providence. It’s really effected me. I’m not sure I understand how it was possible to keep me apart for so long, and not worth defending and defying the way you did for <The Brother>’s girlfriend, not worth welcoming into your house like you were willing to accept in the joblessness and alchoholism of <Roommate’s Girlfriend>.
Unless you wanted to keep me apart.
It’s been a big deal. It’s become one of the glaring differences between us being “just friends” or “more than friends”. It’s been one of those things that isn’t what I thought we were. When I got kicked out, everyone I knew asked me, at some point, why I’d not just stay with you, when you’d stayed with me so often.
And then I watched your house gain women. Watched from a distance while your roomates had constant company of their “more than friends”.
(and then… the thoughts: why you’d invite others over your house, and tell me no [yes, I am still confused about your stripper party and don’t understand your explanation, and would really appreciate it if you could put that to rest so it’d stop eating my brain, how someone could take a train to your house for your party, needing a ride to your house and a place to crash, all arranged without you knowing]; why you’d keep the painting I made you hidden in a closet; why you’d sleep with me when you knew my emotions were romantic…. and I can’t not think that it’s …. me. That I’m not…. not…. )
It’s… been really difficult…. to not feel awful.
I don’t understand why… when I’d explained to you how it’d made me feel, why it all continued.
Don’t feel bad about my health. Or my artistic output. You didn’t know. You didn’t see it.
But…. if you could explain to me… why you did the things you DID know had negative effects on me… The things that others were offered…
That would help. It would help speed up this chemo process, in one direction or the other.
…..
You’ve said a number of times that it’s the fact that I was the one to hand you a drink. That you’d not expect it from ME of all people. But you beleive that I didn’t do it on purpose to hurt you, right?
That’s the same way I feel about finding out we’d not been exclusive; that you’d rather me find someone else to “really like”.
(I look back at all those intimate moments. Every single kiss having meaning. Moments of trembling and being breathless just from the overwhelming emotions I’d have from kissing you. Feeling for so long that… you were my heart. My absolutely everything. My romantic ideal. And finding out that … you’d not been there with me. )
Neither were said to hurt. Neither were done to hurt. But they hurt.
Because …. we both thought… we were understood. That’s where the real hurt comes from. That we thought we knew. We thought… we had finally found someone who really and truly understands the important parts. And we got hurt in really vulnerable places where neither of us really trust anyone enough to let in. And now we look back and wonder about all those moments of close, and wonder if it was real at all, when there’s something so important we got wrong for each other.
Both looking at each other, and thinking “but you were supposed to KNOW.”
But see….
That’s the kind of thing that can be fixed. That can be mended by learning.
Hurting by accident is always forgivable.
September 16th 2010
email from me
Here’s my train of thought at the moment:
I’d tried…. to bring us on events. Like…. dates sorta. To find new things for us. New memories. That was one of the other tactics I’d tried. The museum day…. the Faith no More Show… were failures.
My not being allowed to stay over your house… That isn’t a reaonable request from a roommate. I mean, seriously. Not leaving the windows open overnight, not playing movies too late when people are sleeping, ok, that’s a “well, you live with people, you gotta compromize” sort of thing. But to have an issue with a fellow housemate having female company because of bathroom use is…. insane. You are adult men. having an overnight guest even once week is totally normal.
This has never been an issue of me trying to pry in to your life. It’s…. It’s really hurt that you’d cater to uch an obviously out-there request…. when that’d mean we couldn’t ever share a bed together. There were so many small issues of home politics that you’d told me you’d move out over without blinking an eye. And me coming over was never on that list.
I…. I got shit from my family about you staying over so often. It caused some stress. I don’t know if that’ played into <StepMom>’s wierd and cryptic complaint of me being “disrespectful” But…. to imply I couldn’t have overnight guests when I wanted was unreasonable, and that time together with you was too important to me. I didn’t tell you for probably the same reason you didn’t tell me. But I fought for it. I’m glad I did. It was always worth it.
And it isn’t the issue in itself. It’s… it just makes me then wonder how important that time was to you, if complaints about hair in the shower drain would keep me away. Like I wonder what our intimacy meant to you, when it became a romantic sharing to me by that first winter, and I wa so consumed by you even then that nobody would ever catch my attention while you were a part of my l ife.
And like everything else, the ituations go in pairs. If we go forward, then… I don’t have to think about what happened before. If you have issue of the past and who we were with, than I’m stuck there too.
So,
If you come over to my house 4 days in a row, it only glaringly points out how unwelcome I am in your home, and all that brings. That we are sitting here, on my couch, quietly, franticly checking the clock to make ure you leave on time…. instead of bonding in pajamas watching movies. My favorite moment with you are the pajama times.
so… I tried dates.
New memories.
New patterns.
Now… crazy as I am….
I saw that Eraserhead is playing at midnight at the IFC this weekend. And I thought maybe…. we could have a day. A glorious autumnal day in the city.
But
I remembered that I’m on my way to <Vermont Friend>’s wedding, if my head behaves. I’ll end up catching a ride with the middle brother, I think. I’d wanted to bring you. I’d liked to have seen you in a suit. I;d liked the idea of you actually being my “date” to something. I’d be proud. In your stead, I was going to bring this fellow Bart – He’s a college/Drew friend who happened to be <Vermont Friend>’s second cousin. He cancelled last week.
And today I thought… maybe that’s fortunate. Maybe… you’d….
Maybe this could be the NewEngland weekend you thought I meant.
Maybe you’d go with me, even if my hair is silly.
There’s gonna be a petting zoo.
Maybe… the past could really not matter so much.
Maybe that’s too much to expect at the moment.
Maybe I should just go by myself and accept the fact that we shouldn’t be together, and let this be a first step in really truly separating myself from you.
I hope your headache feel better.
email from Stefan
I’ve read and heard a lot in the last few days. I’ve explained again and again that our situations aren’t comparable, have different legal bindings, and there is a difference between a house with no people…and a house with….other people. I have explained (to your dissatisfaction of course) what it’s like to be me in this house and how I am not <The Brother>, or anyone else who lives here. I am Stefan. There is no comparing. You’ll only hurt yourself and come to poorly thought out conclusions with lots of room for self deprecation to fill in the blanks of an already badly thought out scale of comparison.
I hate being compared to people….but you do it constantly. And even after last night. Again…letting you tell me what you want, and question me (again), I gave you whatever answers I could, and you seemed a tad pleased. Now, today…you write to me making sure I know that once again, everything I said, went right through you and all the same comparisons continue. But not only that….but you have a new thing to blame me for. Getting kicked out of your house. Thanks. I didn’t even finish my coffee yet and you tell me I’m (once again) the reason for a terrible thing that happened to you. Then you throw a barrage of underhanded comments of how you sacrifice for me where I wouldn’t and didn’t for you. I could give a thousand examples of things I’ve done for you that haven’t been reciprocated but that’s because I understand that people do what they can, and I don’t compare my feats to yours. You do. Still do. Always will.
As soon as I read ,” it just makes me then wonder how important that time was to you”…I just about had it. I didn’t erase it. I just scrolled down to reply. I’m tired of waking up to insults and blame. This is why I told you I’m done with you.
If you have something rude to write in response, or you don’t like my opinions, just erase this and leave me alone. I’m constantly assessed, insulted, and compared by you. I think I’ve tolerated quite a bit in the last two weeks, and despite you telling me I was yelling, I still listened, and let you ask me questions. And, tried to answer them.
This i a bit much to read right now considering I didn’t even drink coffee yet, and I had a dream I was on a slow roller coaster made of pulsing entrails and woke up frantic. If you can’t understand or respect my feelings…please leave me alone. Much like you wonder how much our time meant to me, I wonder (all the time) how much my feelings mean to you.
This is what’s on my mind.
I’ll read the rest of this later. I hope it doesn’t get worse.
email from me
I wasn’t comparing you to <The Brother>.
I was comparing you to you. There was a whole host of times and thing that you’d said to me were issues for which you’d move out without hesitation, but something as honestly bizarre as not being allowed to have an overnight guest any more frequently than once every two months, something far and beyond reasonable expectation, wasn’t one of them. I was asking why. I was asking how you felt about that.
I never ever EVER blamed you for getting me kicked out of my house. I chose to have you over. I chose to keep to myself any sort of stresses that caused. I didn’t tell you. I didn’t want you to feel uncomfortable or unwelcome, and felt they’d no right to dictate what I did. I did it, not you.
There were no insults whatsoever in my email.
Look…. I’m not trying to say that I’m more willing to sacrifice across the board. I’m wondering where the focus is. I’m wondering if our physically intimate times were as important and integral a part of our interaction as they were to me, or if…. even then, and even on that level, I was more engaged in the sexual/romantic aspect of us, and if you have always seen that as something less important, as delicious but perhaps unnecessary icing on the cake of us, and are perfectly satiated to just sit on a couch and only touch when we hug goodbye. To me, that’s a situation that leaves me wanting and sad. To you, maybe it’s enough.
(( There are parts of me that I’ve never shared with anyone ever but you, many vulnerable places I never show, and most of those manifest in the physical. I’m not very good at expressing… at saying… um… y’know… the mooshy stuff. But…. I can scream my love for you like a banshee through the way I touch you, and give myself entirely over. It’s… only you. Only you. ))
Regardless, I feel it’s important to figure that out. It might explain some of the tangles.
Being that we’ve not had any definitions, any real talk about what things mean for a very long time and were coming to our own concluions, there ARE going to be comparions between us. The whole deal of things wierd between us is a difference in how I feel for you, how you feel for me, and what we feel are the boundaries we each personally hold that to.
When I tell you that something hurts me, I’m not calling you a monster. When I tell you that something upset me, I’m not insulting you. I’m telling you how I feel, and how things effect me.
If you could separate that, if you could maybe keep that in mind, it might keep from you feeling like I’m attacking you, blaming you, and insulting you. I cannot help the way I feel, and I’m trying to communicate with you, not accuse you, or win points. Perhaps if you kept that perspective in mind while reading back anything I’d written to you, you might see my words in a different light. You might see less finger pointing, and more “these are where my scars are. where are yours? why do we have them?”
I do desperately care about your feelings. I’m trying to understand them. I’m begging for understanding. But then, when I ask, you often feel I’m accusing and interrogating. Honestly, I’ve wondered for a very long time how you felt about me, about us being together, how important our relationship was, how intimate our sexual relationhip was, if you were still interested in being sexual with someone else. This isn’t accusation. This is me trying to understand your feelings on things.
Maybe if I did, i’d not be so hurt about certain things. Maybe if I weren’t so hurt, you’d not feel like a monster.
I hope you read the rest of my other email.